It should be noted that where a statutory demand is set aside, costs are most often awarded against the debtor. However, a statutory demand does not guarantee settlement of the debt. These three cases illustrate that strict compliance with legislative requirements continues to be imperative when serving statutory demands. If you lose, youll have to pay back your debt within the 21 day time limit. It is up to you to convince the court that there is a genuine dispute. Genuine disputes and offsetting claims the threshold 8 8. Setting aside a statutory demand worrells solvency. Setting aside a creditors statutory demand on the basis of a dispute a creditors statutory demand is an effective tool used by creditors to compel a debtor company to pay its outstanding debts.
Guide to statutory demands for those presenting and. Costs risk on serving a statutory demand a cautionary. We withdrew a statutory demand following the other sides application to set it aside. Statutory demand under section 2682 of the insolvency act 1986 blank statutory demand form 63 setting aside a statutory demand. If you have questions about setting aside a creditors statutory demand, get in touch with legalvisions dispute resolution lawyers on 0 544 755 or fill out the form on this. The forms will need to be submitted to the high court, along with a copy of the statutory demand if you still have it. How to draft a statutory demand form 509h stonegate legal. Some other reason for setting aside the demand 11 10.
Fact sheet 36 ew statutory demands statutory demands page 1. Ignore it, and risk winding up proceedings being commenced against the company. In these circumstances, the court will almost always award substantial costs against the creditor. We often hear complaints about other solicitors and the way in which they charge especially for work involving statutory demands.
A company may apply to the court for an order setting aside a statutory demand served on the company. Fact sheet 36 ew statutory demands statutory demands. Commercial law update setting aside a statutory demand. In brief statutory demands under section 459e of the corporations act. If, however, the set aside application is dismissed, the time for the company to comply with the demand will be extended until 7 days after the date of the dismissal, unless the court. The starting point in this instance is section 459g of the corps act which provides. A small mistake in the demand about the amount owed will not make it invalid. If a company owes you a debt, or debts, of more that the statutory demand statutory minimum, which at the time of writing this, section 9 of the corporations act 2001 cth says. Application to set aside a statutory demand a insert name and address of person to attend hearing let a attend before the registrar as follows. After the period of 21 day from the statutory demand being served the person issuing the statutory demand may begin the process that petitions the persons bankruptcy. Setting aside a statutory demand another useful summary.
An application to set aside a statutory demand must be made with a court that has appropriate jurisdiction being a states supreme court or the federal court. In the recent case of ramesh mohandas nagrani v united overseas bank ltd 2015 sghc 266, the singapore high court had to decide whether to set aside a statutory demand based on alleged irregularities in its contents, and touched on what makes a statutory demand invalid. Insolvency and restructuring, litigation and dispute resolution, banking and financial services. Setting aside a statutory demand in bankruptcy proceedings. Challenging a statutory demand serve all evidence within. If the statutory demand is setaside, this can result in an order for costs being made against. Application to set aside a statutory demand ashfords. A statutory demand can, in appropriate circumstances, offer the solution. How not to serve an application to set aside a statutory demand nov 2, 2015 when a company receives a creditors statutory demand for payment of debt statutory demand which is perhaps defective or the subject of a dispute, it is often possible to apply to the court for orders that the statutory demand be set aside. There is no formal procedure to apply to set aside a statutory demand where it was served on a company, however failure to deal with the demand may mean that a winding up petition is presented. Courts can set aside statutory demands but will only do this if there is a genuine dispute about whether the debt exists. Costs risk on serving a statutory demand a cautionary tale from the court of appeal. It considers the procedure for applying to set aside a statutory demand served on an individual and the issues which may subsequently arise.
A party who is served with a statutory demand can also apply to set aside the demand where they convince the court there is a genuine dispute between the parties about the debt or that they have an offsetting claim. Where an individual has guaranteed the debts of a third party it is sometimes seen as an easy route to recovery of monies owed, for the creditor to serve a statutory demand on the guarantor. Several elements of the demand need to be carefully checked, including the legitimacy of the specified debt whether it is correct in full or only in part, and if the required legal procedures have been followed by the sender. If you think you have a valid ground to set aside a statutory demand, you must bring an application to set it aside within 21 days of receiving the statutory demand. If the court sets the statutory demand aside, the demand will be of no force or effect and no presumption of insolvency will arise as a result of noncompliance. If a debtor company applies to set the demand aside, and is successful because of a defect in the demand, then you may be ordered to pay the debtor companys legal costs for the. The deadline for paying the debt will be suspended. The insolvency court is not a court of debt collection. Lenders are increasingly subject to applications by debtors to have the demand set aside. Debts claimed in statutory demands must be due and payable to the creditor named in the statutory demand. Setting aside a statutory demand is complicated and in addition to the information in this fact sheet, you may.
If the debtor company fails to pay the debt or come to a suitable arrangement with the creditor or make an application to set it aside within that time period, then the company is presumed to be insolvent. It is often the case, that where a statutory demand has been served on a debtor, the debtor wishes to dispute its validity. Alternatively, use the mouse to click from one field to the next. If a statutory demand is made, the company served with the demand has 21 days to pay the debt or otherwise secure the amount of the debt to the creditors satisfaction or to apply to the court pursuant to section 459g of the act to have the demand set aside. In dunhill v hughmans a firm 2017 ewhc 2073 ch, the court of appeal held that the appellant dunhill was entitled to be paid her costs for her successful application to set aside a statutory demand served on her by hughmans. You might assume that a statutory demand under s2681 is a demand for payment. If that company does not comply with the statutory demand or apply to the court to set the statutory demand aside within 21 days then the company is deemed to be insolvent. Date time hours place b insert name of debtor on the hearing of an application by b the applicant for an order that the statutory demand dated be set aside.
To successfully get a statutory demand set aside one or more of the following must. You can apply to the court to have a statutory demand set aside, as long as you do it within 18 days of the demand being served. Setting aside a statutory demand complete guide stonegate legal. A genuine dispute between the company and the respondent about the existence or amount of a debt to which the demand. Statutory demand against an individual general procedure. Statutory demand costs can be much cheaper than proceeding by way of normal court litigation. At simon burn solicitors we take a proactive approach to costs. Companies which are served with a statutory demand have 21 days to apply to the court to have it set aside. The purpose of a statutory demand is to prevent debtors from delaying matters by filing nonsense defences to liquidated claims. In circumstances where the statutory demand debt is undisputed, it can sensible to proceed with a statutory demand as the statutory demand costs can often be much cheaper than the court fees payable to commence a county court or high court claim.
Insolvency rules application to set aside a statutory demand. Setting aside a statutory demand is something which a debtor can do if the debt is disputed or it has a cross claim which overreaches the amount of the statutory demand claim. If you win your case, youll get an order from the court setting aside the statutory demand. Insolvency proceedings practice direction courts and tribunals. Contracting out of a right to assert an offsetting claim 12 11. Creditors can make a statutory demand for payment of a debt under section 459e of the corporations act as long as the debt is due and payable. A company that is served with a statutory demand must either pay the amount referred to in the demand or apply to set aside the demand under s. Statutory demands are a formal way of asking for a debt to be paid get the forms to send, cancel or set aside a statutory demand. Bankruptcy statutory forms department for the economy. We strongly recommend getting a statutory demand solicitor to draft the demand for you. If you dispute the debt you can apply to the county court for the statutory demand to be set aside. Make and serve a statutory demand, or challenge one gov. This approach does, therefore, create more risk in regards to costs for the applicant seeking to set aside a demand but, fortunately, in practice it appears that the courts are still very alert to the potential for misuse of the statutory demand procedure the insolvency court is not a court of debt collection. The creditor can apply to bankrupt you if you do not pay in time and your debt is.
Statutory demands are quick, simple and relatively inexpensive to present, and can be a vital tool in a lender attempting to get a debtor to pay its debt. Affidavit in support of application to set aside statutory. Contact business debtline on 0800 197 6026 for help. Effect of noncompliance with a statutory demand 6 6. In the final article of our series on statutory demands, we discuss setting aside a statutory demand. Statutory demand for payment of debt stonegate legal. Failure to comply with the requirements may, in extreme cases, provide grounds for setting aside the demand. It requires a debtor company to pay a debt it owes within 21 days. Application to set aside a statutory demand rule 47. Statutory demands australian institute of credit management. There are four bases upon which the alleged debtor company can have the statutory. In setting aside the statutory demand the court of appeal followed the approach that the expression genuine dispute involves a party raising a plausible contention requiring investigation. Defects in the demand and substantial injustice 9 9. Upon seeing the application and evidence in support, x withdraws the statutory demand.
Applying to set aside a creditors statutory demand for. Statutory demands for restructuring and insolvency professionals. Statutory demand for monies under on demand guarantee. The court might also consider an application outside this time limit, as long as the creditor hasnt already asked for. A statutory demand can be served as soon as the debt is due or in advance of an upcoming debt, without warning and a county court judgment is not necessary, unless it is for a debt regulated by the consumer credit act 1974.
The last thing you want is to be faced with a situation where you want to apply to set aside a creditors statutory demand but you are unable to do so because you have miscalculated the expiration of the 21 day period, or because the courts are closed because it is a public holiday. Make and serve a statutory demand, or challenge one. Given the consequences of an adverse costs order in such. Setting aside a statutory demand is complicated and in addition to the information in this fact sheet, you may need advice. The court has indicated that the hearing is vacated. The most common ground for setting aside a statutory demand is a genuine dispute about the existence or the amount of the debt the statutory demand claims. Statutory demands setting aside winding up petition. An application may only be made within 21 days after the demand is so served. It is imperative that you act promptly you have in the first instance only 18 days as of right to apply to the court for a set aside once you have received a statutory demand. In this case, the plaintiff had entered into a settlement agreement and a consent judgment with the defendants. Grounds to set aside a statutory demand business debtline. If you have been served and are wanting to get a demand set aside, then read our page setting aside a demand. Who bears the costs of an application to set aside a statutory demand.
A debtor applied to set aside a statutory demand served on him. Setting aside a statutory demand because of a genuine dispute, offsetting. Who bears the costs of an application to set aside a. Setting aside a statutory demand served on a company. A statutory demand is a document issued by a creditor. Mr martin sought to set aside the second statutory demand aside on various. Exactly the same considerations apply where the guarantor wishes to have the statutory demand set aside. The demand must be signed and dated by the creditor or a person authorised to sign on the creditors behalf. That on b the statutory demand exhibited hereto and marked a came into my hands. The rules about statutory demands for limited companies and partnerships are different. Some of the potential grounds for setting aside a statutory demand were raised in tan hup yuan patrick v the griffin coal mining co pty ltd administrators appointed and others 2014 sghc 156. Affidavit in support of application to set aside statutory demand a insert name address and description of person making the oath i a make oath and say as follows. Apply to have a statutory demand cancelled citizens advice. Affidavit in support of application to set aside statutory demand.
825 239 1288 1330 388 820 939 916 174 1289 1655 464 138 1477 78 1289 14 16 1379 1391 648 1213 1078 418 1167 1274 741 398 1181 884 1283 940 35 805 965 25 1131 1186 304 483 1008 1212 398 954 1119 672 835 159 66